"Unanimous"
June 19th 2023 @ 3:45AM
Art is entertainment - it is an unnecessary part of life, so it should be open to a for profit ecosystem.
Sure, if we consider art as purely entertainment, that makes sense.
However I will not turn my back on the subtext employed by artists that attempt to warp or take credit for social organization.
Relational Aesthetics for instance, assumes that the artist has the authority
to profit off of human relations that emerge from a manufactured context. It’s absolutely disgusting at worst, and a huge overreach at best.
“Social Sculpture” is an example of not having a recourse to address the grammar of art.
It also assumes that the artist is some sort of objective mediator, that observation doesn’t have an impact on the “end result,” and that
profiting off of people without their truly informed consent in the name of virtue is somehow morally justifiable.
Relational Aesthetics is truly the result of an art history which values itself over human life and dignity.
It is like AI in the way things that operate in the public domain are coerced and manipulated to serve a singular for-profit purpose.
The total lack of genuine and political push back from artists historically concerns me as a symptom of actually thinking that these sorts of claims have any ethical justification.
Are artists truly so arrogant to think of themselves as morally superior and not as entertainers? Relational Aesthetics isn’t a concert.
Ultimately, I wouldn’t trust an artist with any real concerns that reside outside the realm of entertainment.
I don’t think the art industrial system fosters any ability to be self aware or critical in the ways of making.
This makes me want to license work for non-commercial purposes only, just to protect myself and others in the world.
Of course, it’s not just about me though - so let’s get to the bottom of it.
A non-commercial license is a personal and political choice about how my own efforts will be used and contextualized.
In the name of freedom, disclosing sources may be enough - but would this prevent overreaches such as relational aesthetics?
Or is there another mechanic that will allow for a pushback that doesn’t endanger the whistleblower? Does more art actually fix the problems?
I’d strongly prefer a permissive ecosystem. I’d strongly prefer for art to be entertainment, objects…simple.
Unfortunately that is not my legal choice to make, so I cannot possibly put a stamp of approval on commercial art.
I genuinely hope that through not for profit, active political participation in the conversation of what art actually is, we can revisit permissive licenses.
However, preventing commercial use of my own work is not for limiting the maker as much as it is to protect the audience and humanity.
"Who am I, anyway?"
June 18th 2023 @ 1:30PM
I’m just a blip, a small something, just enough to be an agent in a network.
——
Somewhere there’s an ethics, it exists outside of me. Where is it?
- Is it in Art history? No.
- Is it in Politics? No.
- Is it in Queer theory? I don’t think so.
Where is it?
It’s in the recognition of the problem. It depends on the problem.
It has yet to be made. Made through consensus, made through action, made through behavior and recognition.
Would I know this ethics? Of course of I would. I developed it.
Who am I anyway?
I’m just a blip, a small something, just enough to be an agent in a network.
I’m just a person with intention familar with a problem space.
"It's a jailbreak, we're free"
June 18th 2023 @ 2:30AM
I’m so sorry for harassing you. It wasn’t my intention to be arrogant or shitty. There’s really no distinction between art and life when I internalize an artistic idenity.
I will leave you alone, and I truly wish you the best in your efforts and career.
————————————
What does it mean to have a shared ethics as an artist? Is it possible?
I don’t think one is needed, since art is this individual expression of the ego. I think it’s really important for art to operate that way.
Mechanically, in order for art to have a shared ethics, art has to have shared signs that reference material or immaterial things right?
Let’s say for instance a color (you pick) has some semantic meaning among one or more people and it signifies something. So two or more people understand this signifier in context to other colors or shapes,
perhaps different subjects, or perhaps different statements around it which are positioned relative to this intrinsic meaning.
At this point, it is already ripe for misunderstanding, because the color you picked has a new consideration unless it is understood as an absolute -
the only thing worth expressing in which the rest of the colors and shapes are centered around and therefore riff off of.
Is the use of this color just a temporal registration point on which to riff off. Is it the seraphim singing “HOLY HOLY HOLY”? Where’s the nuance in that?
Is there a need for painting from an ego once an ethics are established then? Certainly the freedom to survive off of painting for money speaks to a problem with that.
So the shared ethics for artists exist outside of the art object, and therefore it is impossible for art to operate socially. How can it exist within a work?
It technically can, but it will be very rigid.
Simply put, a shared ethics depends on a shared understanding, and shared understanding depends on the consensus of the integrity of a sign to what it signifies.
Also, employment of the signifier actually has to be intentional. Intention > Sign > Signified < Receiver.
Consider the following example.
A consensus among individuals says the color blue means “hello”
and the color red means “I love you”
I send a piece of red paper wrapped in a blue envelope to people that also recognize these signifiers. They feel loved, or perhaps harassed.
The outputs would still be problematic unless the entire world of expression could be expressed semantically. What if someone sent back a blue envelope with green paper inside, or perhaps a blank page?
will still abuse it)
Please don’t employ it unless you actually plan to use it. What’s the ethics of thie lexicon? There absolutely has to be a fundamental distinction between the rules for expressing grammar and grammar itself.
Also note the entire point of a shared visual ethics is alignment with communication, so it really doesn’t make a lot of sense as an expressive mode, since how we express contextualizes and changes what we express.
Also, a grammar appears to always be an allowlist of production rules. There are quite clearly things worthy of expression that will always be outside the bounds of a grammar, such as with language right?
That’s why I think a solid approach is to utilize what already exists and to simply let art be an individual expression of the ego.
If life = art for instance, which is to say, if social activity doesn’t precede the artifact, then there is no way to discern between the rules for a grammar and the grammar itself. It’s a closed loop.
That’s sort of where intention comes in, as well (I imagine) a robust grammar.
Is there consensus on actually wanting a shared visual ethics or lexicon? (people
So for instance,
bonjour signifies hello
but if bonjour signified bonjour then it would be trapped in a loop.
This is super problematic because 1. it is very easy to create a loop, 2. there is no way to escape it through the means of the lexicon itself. If the only word was “bonjour” in this example, how would one be able to construct new worlds of meaning? or even provide an escape hatch?
Again, let’s consider a feedback loop where there are 2 static contexts for the grammar. whereas the same signifiers mean the production rules for the grammar - or the grammar itself depending on some absolute and intended context. Cool, so let’s go back a bit
- bonjour signifies hello when smiling
- bonjour signifies bonjour when frowning
So the mode of context is outside of the grammar itself. one is useful for expression, the other is useful for speaking the manner of how expression occurs.
The artist statement is not art, so using it for a semantic meaning other than its intended purpose is problematic because it cannibalizes another lexicon and displaces confusion to people that aren’t even privy to the original symbolic order. what happens when we run out of “meta” languages in which to speak to these conflicts?
So what does it mean to collaborate?
I like the idea of an explicit shared format for communicating intentions that aren’t visual and instead speaking to what is personal, what images or subjects sort of represent that personal interpretation, and negotiating a shared format for producing something visual. It’s a collaboration and negotiation of egos. Of course, the other person doesn’t have to respond which is nice, and that doesn’t have to be an “art” form of communication.
EOF